Methodology
How every number on the site is made, and how much to trust it.
Where the data comes from
- Checklists and odds: the manufacturer's published checklist and odds sheet for each product, parsed card by card and version by version. Box configuration (packs per box, encased hits, boxes per case) comes from the product's official details.
- Break prices: breakers' public store listings (Layton Sports Cards, The Clubhouse, Firehand Cards and Cardsmiths), read once a day at 10:00 ET. A break that lists only its unsold teams counts toward those teams' prices but not toward whole-break totals. Each listing's format (pick your team, random team, division) and size (boxes opened) are read from its title.
- Sealed box prices: the same stores' sealed box and case listings, recorded daily per box. History starts the day we started recording; it isn't backfilled.
- Product images: the images breakers attach to their listings of the product, usually the manufacturer's promotional slides. We show only images reused across listings, link each one back to its source, and don't host copies.
Spot prices
Prices are compared like for like: the same product, box type, format and break size. Within that, every shop gets one vote: we take each shop's median for the spot, then average the shops. A shop listing twelve breaks counts the same as a shop listing one, so the price isn't just whoever lists the most. Each spot shows the shops behind it. A team's spot price uses every listing of that team, including breaks that list only their unsold teams. The whole break averages each shop's median break total over complete breaks; it isn't the sum of the team prices (the two differ when a team is cheap in one break and dear in another). Where no break of a size is listed, we scale the case price by the box count and mark it estimate; a division with no listings shows its teams' spots added up. Markup compares the whole break with the same boxes bought sealed.
Expected cards and chances
Each odds line (“Rookie Autographs Gold /50, 1:55”) says how often that version falls. Pulls of a version = packs opened ÷ odds, split evenly over the cards in its subset. Encased hits use the hit count: Pristine's hit odds are per encased hit, three per box. A team's expected autos add up every autograph version of its players' cards; a dual card is split between the two players' teams in proportion to player value. (The Odds tab counts a dual card fully for each player on it, since either way you'd own it.)
Chance of at least one = 1 − e−expected (pulls treated as independent), and “1 in N boxes” is 1 ÷ the per-box rate. Real boxes are collated, so the chance of a second hit of the same kind in one box is lower than this, but the average over many boxes is the same. As a check, every autograph line of the Pristine sheet adds up to its guaranteed 3 encased autos per box, and our per-team card and serial-number totals match independent checklist sites.
Cost per auto = spot price ÷ expected autos.
Estimated value
Est. value is a model: each card version is priced at its kind's anchor for the player's tier (e.g. a tier-S base auto), then scaled up by how much rarer that version is than the kind's most common one. How steeply it scales is learned from real sales: we collect ladders of the same card sold at different print runs (a player's /99, /25, /5 and 1/1), and fit the curve separately for star rookies, whose rare parallels climb much faster, and for everyone else. A spot's value is its expected pulls × those prices: the average over many breaks. A few rare hits pull that average up, so most breaks come in under it. That's why every team also shows its typical value (the middle result of 5,000 simulated case breaks) and its chance to break even (how often the cards are worth at least the spot price); tap a team for the full picture, including a typical break card by card. Value per $ = average value ÷ spot price, so above 1.00× the cards average more than the spot costs. Team estimates are good to about ±30%, so we only call a spot Good value at 1.3× or more andPricey at 0.7× or less. Values are sale prices: selling a card costs fees and postage on top.
Where one of the product's own cards has actually sold (raw, not graded), that sold price replaces the model's number for that card. Sales come from two places: sold listings from The Card API, and notable sales reported publicly (auction results and hobby news), each stored with its source link. The anchors are still editorial, so use est. value to compare spots rather than as a resale price.
Every product's Card values tab lists the estimate for every card and parallel, sortable, so you can see exactly what the model assumes.
Player tiers
Every player on a checklist gets a tier, S A B C, from current hobby demand: S is the handful of names that carry a product (for Pristine: Flagg, Wembanyama, the top rookies), C is everyone unlisted. Tiers set the anchor prices above, so they drive how value splits between teams. They're reviewed by hand for each product.
WaxMath score
Not shown yet. With one product there's nothing to compare a score against, so we've hidden it until there are several. This is how it will work. One number, 0 to 100, for a product's hobby box, built only from the data above. Three parts, each mapped onto 0–100 over a fixed range:
- Value (35%): est. value of a box's cards ÷ the sealed box price. 0.5× scores 0, 1.0× scores 100.
- Chase (35%): tier-S autographs per $1,000 of sealed boxes, i.e. how much money it takes to reach the names that carry the product. 0 scores 0, 0.5 scores 100.
- Break premium (30%): how much a pick-your-team case costs over the same boxes sealed. 40% over scores 0; at or under sealed scores 100.
80+ is Strong, 60–79 Good, 40–59 Fair, below 40 Weak. A part with no data (no break listings yet, say) is left out and the others are re-weighted. The ranges are provisional: they were set on our first product and will be recalibrated once there are several to compare. Value and chase lean on the tier model, so they carry its limits (below). Community ratings, when they come, will sit next to this score, not inside it.
Formats and print runs
Every way to buy it compares a product's formats (hobby, FDI, instant packs...) using each format's own odds column: expected autos, numbered cards, parallels and inserts per box or pack, and the chance of a /25-or-rarer auto or a 1/1. Cost per divides the price by each count, at the release price and, where we track stores, today's lowest in-stock price.
Print runs aren't published, but the numbered parallels give them away. A version numbered /25 across a 40-card subset exists in exactly 1,000 copies. If the odds say it falls 1 in 110 packs in the only format that has it, that format was about 110,000 packs. Formats without a version of their own are solved from shared versions, after subtracting the formats already known. Each figure is the median across every version that informs it. For 2025-26 Topps Pristine Basketball this gives about 1.61 million cards in total, within 2% of an independent estimate.
Simulator, live board, personal rips
- Simulator: opens every pack by drawing each version at its published odds (a random, unsaved rip). Rip a few times to see the swing.
- Live board: tap teams as they're taken; no prices needed. In a random team break or auction, the next spot wins a random team from those left, so it's worth the average spot price of the remaining teams (× teams per spot). It falls when a chase team goes and rises as cheap teams clear. In pick your team, each team is worth its own spot price; optional sale prices show whether the room runs over or under the market. Bid below the going price by takes that share off every bid.
- Personal Break: for sealed boxes you open yourself: cost vs the typical (median) and average value of the contents, expected cards, and chances as above for N boxes.
- Checklist: every card in the product, searchable by player, team, card number or set, with filters for card type, set, team and rookies.
- Odds: pick a player or team to add up all their cards and parallels; per-box odds use the same rates.
News and smart alerts
Each day's market is saved as a snapshot. Market alerts compare it with the previous day: a team spot moving at least 5% and $10, a whole break moving at least 3%, a flat spot (random team) moving 5%, or new breaks listed; they also carry a weekly read on breaks vs sealed and a market recap. Releases cover checklists posted or updated and guides going live. News is different: hobby headlines from Cardlines, Checklist Insider and Basketball Card Insider, fetched daily. We show the headline, source and date and link to the original; we don't copy the article.
What we don't know
- Listed prices, not what spots sold for. A break that fills below list isn't visible to us.
- Only the breakers we read. Two stores is a thin market; we add breakers as we find public listings.
- Est. value is a model, not sales (above).
- Odds are the manufacturer's averages over the whole print run.
Spot a number that looks off? That's the feedback we want most. Back to the break guides